Em 0038

Source content

{

"id": "EM-0038",

"title": "Govern the MCP research-submission queue",

"status": "ready",

"change_class": "governance-normative",

"objective": "Introduce a separate authenticated MCP contribution authority that accepts validated research-proposal bundles into a durable review queue, returns immutable intake receipts, and can never directly admit evidence, change public truth, merge code, or publish a case.",

"depends_on": [

"EM-0037"

],

"authority": {

"allowed_paths": [

"constitution/**",

"policies/**",

"schemas/**",

"governance/events/**",

"src/**",

"tests/**",

"docs/**",

"ops/**",

"runs/**",

".github/**"

],

"forbidden_paths": [

"research/**",

"catalog/dossiers/**",

"tasks/contracts/**"

]

},

"required_evaluation": [

"independent governance review loaded from the accepted base branch before implementation approval",

"threat model for anonymous and authenticated intake, prompt injection, data exfiltration, spam, denial of service, replay, duplicate submission, identity spoofing, and malicious attachments",

"least-privilege GitHub App or equivalent persistence review with no contents-write, pull-request, workflow, deployment, package, administration, or merge authority",

"append-only queue state machine, idempotency key, canonical bundle digest, immutable receipt, submitter-visible status, rejection and withdrawal semantics, retention policy, and audit trail",

"strict separation between coordination queue records and accepted Git-canonical epistemic events",

"MCP write-tool transport, authentication, Origin, body-size, rate-limit, timeout, structured-error, and annotation conformance",

"independent evaluator and promoter separation with no shared authoring-agent self-approval",

"provider deployment, secret handling, log redaction, incident rollback, abuse monitoring, cost cap, external smoke, and public availability read-back"

],

"acceptance": [

"submit_research_proposal accepts only a valid EM-0037 bundle plus an idempotency key and returns a queue ID, bundle digest, received timestamp, status, and non-admission notice",

"the durable queue uses coordination-only records with explicit submitted, triaged, needs-evidence, accepted-for-review, rejected, and withdrawn states",

"queue acceptance never creates an accepted dossier, alters a public count, opens or merges a pull request, changes policy, or publishes a page",

"promotion from accepted-for-review requires a separately authorized source-capture and independent-review workflow that produces a normal protected pull request",

"the submission service has no repository contents-write, pull-request, workflow, deployment, package, administration, DNS, or merge permission",

"invalid, duplicate, replayed, oversized, private, secret-shaped, or unsupported submissions fail closed and leave auditable non-sensitive outcomes",

"public status and agent instructions report the exact queue endpoint, supported bundle version, limits, retention, privacy boundary, and current availability only after provider read-back"

],

"limitations": [

"A queued proposal is neither evidence nor knowledge and receives zero warrant or independence credit.",

"GitHub Issues or an equivalent queue are coordination state, not canonical epistemic history.",

"No provider, account, credential, spend, deployment, DNS, public endpoint, or automatic research execution is authorized merely by registering this task.",

"No queue implementation may weaken the existing read-only public gateway or reuse its anonymous deployment identity as write authority."

]

}