# Independent Em0035 Review Receipt - Object ID: `em:research-note:sha256:53b9c834ddf70e7c7b8ecc7f0e2f026c3bc9082d31d46d1a35d09a2941b4612d` - Kind: `research-note` - Repository path: [`research/how-we-know/mehrabian-7-38-55/independent-em0035-review-receipt.json`](https://github.com/yoheinakajima/epistemedia/blob/f92846570180dfa4511263f8ba98ecd18f7772c9/research/how-we-know/mehrabian-7-38-55/independent-em0035-review-receipt.json) - Content digest: `0bb9184660deb3ef83addbcdb7be61d49f234026d6d484747b51628a4f8f087f` **Also filed under:** [Research Program](https://epistemedia.org/topics/research-program/) ## Source content { "bindings": { "accepted_em0033_review": { "bytes": 37799, "path": "research/how-we-know/mehrabian-7-38-55/independent-review-receipt.json", "sha256": "b70e6ae4f073004cc602860bf0a1c3976d6c7fb12c3440253e68a8ff20538d1b" }, "accepted_packet": { "bytes": 65077, "packet_id": "em:research-packet:sha256:a73dc29f0a0c3f05a112b7c392d115cfcc38a1136a683325bf74bebf0c6b2e40", "path": "research/how-we-know/mehrabian-7-38-55/candidate-packet.json", "sha256": "6253a8ece3bb3b5bfb393ec04ad4e0f14b88f567ddea2923300538eadb7c8cde" }, "accepted_source_records": { "bytes": 53857, "path": "research/how-we-know/mehrabian-7-38-55/source-records.json", "sha256": "0ac4f87236882d32aa6018e50600a79642b87acdf05e27c291514e770fda081c" }, "candidate_documentation": [ { "bytes": 5690, "path": "research/how-we-know/mehrabian-7-38-55/DOSSIER.md", "sha256": "b748419fce0196a25ab68c2e8ea5ed43be00280b6738ecedfca61d7a4531b8f8" }, { "bytes": 5401, "path": "docs/execution-plans/EM-0035.md", "sha256": "a40ac91113c51de5e387df45ba5a8848aa5dde870605028ae25b8943746804be" } ], "candidate_dossier": { "bytes": 176885, "dossier_id": "em:dossier:sha256:57e80c9a44c478c1c81ba7adedc1bafdef43ff57b4f2984015dcbef84ba66e87", "path": "research/how-we-know/mehrabian-7-38-55/candidate-dossier.json", "sha256": "44e7bf407091d7665d4f1ab2aabc285255364e790e2d17520913f9ba9c57b418" } }, "commands": [ { "argv": [ "python", "research/how-we-know/mehrabian-7-38-55/build_candidate.py", "--check" ], "completed_at": "2026-08-28T00:18:48Z", "cwd": ".", "exit_code": 0, "started_at": "2026-08-28T00:18:47Z", "stderr_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", "stdout_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855" }, { "argv": [ "python", "research/how-we-know/mehrabian-7-38-55/verify_candidate.py", "--self-test" ], "completed_at": "2026-08-28T00:18:58Z", "cwd": ".", "exit_code": 0, "started_at": "2026-08-28T00:18:57Z", "stderr_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", "stdout_sha256": "0005d07f68988301b640e014cafd94f1f3b2516a4fa9d4c522b635779cb58241" }, { "argv": [ "python", "-m", "ruff", "check", "research/how-we-know/mehrabian-7-38-55" ], "completed_at": "2026-08-28T00:19:12Z", "cwd": ".", "exit_code": 0, "started_at": "2026-08-28T00:19:12Z", "stderr_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", "stdout_sha256": "82b3e6a6c090a57601d22943bd23fca9218d1031dbe5a7b754092f9a156b4f18" }, { "argv": [ "make", "check" ], "completed_at": "2026-08-28T00:20:09Z", "cwd": ".", "exit_code": 0, "started_at": "2026-08-28T00:19:20Z", "stderr_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", "stdout_sha256": "0380d5792576abe0f927af4a409f4c858003300cea2fdab76e80211ddb8c44be" } ], "complete": true, "completed_at": "2026-08-28T00:20:45Z", "coverage": { "accepted_claim_ids": [ "claim-1981-edition", "claim-book-boundary", "claim-hegstrom-rebuttal", "claim-p1-tone-dominance", "claim-p2-face-tone", "claim-popular-rule", "claim-propagation", "claim-related-context", "claim-replication-search", "claim-seven-origin", "claim-three-coefficient-proposal" ], "accepted_derivation_ids": [ "derive-implied-vocal-verbal-ratio", "derive-p2-allocation-with-seven-reserved", "derive-p2-facial-vocal-ratio", "derive-proposed-facial-vocal-ratio", "derive-proposed-sum", "derive-ratio-difference" ], "accepted_lineage_edge_ids": [ "edge-p1-p2-author-social", "edge-p1-p2-grant", "edge-p1-p2-material", "edge-p1-p2-method", "edge-p1-p2-participant", "edge-p1-p2-proposal-derivation", "edge-p1-p2-scale", "edge-p1-p2-speaker", "edge-p1-p2-stimulus", "edge-p2-cites-p1", "edge-silent-messages-editions" ], "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-1981-edition", "assertion-book-boundary", "assertion-derive-implied-vocal-verbal-ratio", "assertion-derive-p2-allocation-with-seven-reserved", "assertion-derive-p2-facial-vocal-ratio", "assertion-derive-proposed-facial-vocal-ratio", "assertion-derive-proposed-sum", "assertion-derive-ratio-difference", "assertion-encyclopedia-evaluation", "assertion-hegstrom-rebuttal", "assertion-p1-tone-dominance", "assertion-p2-face-tone", "assertion-popular-rule", "assertion-propagation", "assertion-related-context", "assertion-replication-search", "assertion-reviewed-source-register", "assertion-seven-origin", "assertion-skeptical-evaluation", "assertion-three-coefficient-proposal" ], "edition_keys": [ "edition-argyle-bjscp-9-3", "edition-argyle-ejsp-1-3", "edition-birmingham-events-20260827", "edition-ctamj-volume-34-article-2", "edition-hampshire-pcc-master-010322", "edition-hegstrom-wjsc-43-2", "edition-kaaj-silent-messages-page-2016", "edition-lapakko-communication-education-46-1", "edition-mehrabian-ferris-jcp-31-3", "edition-mehrabian-wiener-jpsp-6-1", "edition-silent-messages-1971", "edition-silent-messages-1981-second" ], "evaluation_keys": [ "evaluation-encyclopedia", "evaluation-skeptical" ], "follow_up_source_ids": [ "source-argyle-1970", "source-argyle-1971", "source-hegstrom-1979", "source-lapakko-1997", "source-lapakko-2007" ], "lineage_keys": [ "lineage-argyle-related-program", "lineage-author-qualification", "lineage-birmingham-propagation", "lineage-cross-study-proposal", "lineage-follow-up-synthesis", "lineage-general-rule-synthesis", "lineage-hampshire-propagation", "lineage-hegstrom-rebuttal", "lineage-institutional-recirculation", "lineage-lapakko-1997", "lineage-lapakko-2007", "lineage-lapakko-critique-propagation", "lineage-mehrabian-interpretation", "lineage-mehrabian-original-program", "lineage-participant-argyle-1970", "lineage-participant-argyle-1971", "lineage-participant-p1", "lineage-participant-p2", "lineage-propagation-synthesis", "lineage-reviewed-source-register", "lineage-seven-origin-unknown", "lineage-silent-1971", "lineage-silent-1981-unknown" ], "propagation_ids": [ "propagation-birmingham-events", "propagation-hampshire-pcc", "propagation-lapakko-web-sample" ], "proposition_keys": [ "claim-1981-edition", "claim-book-boundary", "claim-hegstrom-rebuttal", "claim-p1-tone-dominance", "claim-p2-face-tone", "claim-popular-rule", "claim-propagation", "claim-related-context", "claim-replication-search", "claim-seven-origin", "claim-three-coefficient-proposal", "derive-implied-vocal-verbal-ratio", "derive-p2-allocation-with-seven-reserved", "derive-p2-facial-vocal-ratio", "derive-proposed-facial-vocal-ratio", "derive-proposed-sum", "derive-ratio-difference", "prop-encyclopedia-evaluation", "prop-reviewed-source-register", "prop-skeptical-evaluation" ], "relation_keys": [ "edge-p1-p2-author-social", "edge-p1-p2-grant", "edge-p1-p2-material", "edge-p1-p2-method", "edge-p1-p2-participant", "edge-p1-p2-proposal-derivation", "edge-p1-p2-scale", "edge-p1-p2-speaker", "edge-p1-p2-stimulus", "edge-p2-cites-p1", "edge-silent-messages-editions", "relation-argyle-context-qualification", "relation-assertion-1981-edition", "relation-assertion-book-boundary", "relation-assertion-derive-implied-vocal-verbal-ratio", "relation-assertion-derive-p2-allocation-with-seven-reserved", "relation-assertion-derive-p2-facial-vocal-ratio", "relation-assertion-derive-proposed-facial-vocal-ratio", "relation-assertion-derive-proposed-sum", "relation-assertion-derive-ratio-difference", "relation-assertion-encyclopedia-evaluation", "relation-assertion-hegstrom-rebuttal", "relation-assertion-p1-tone-dominance", "relation-assertion-p2-face-tone", "relation-assertion-popular-rule", "relation-assertion-propagation", "relation-assertion-related-context", "relation-assertion-replication-search", "relation-assertion-reviewed-source-register", "relation-assertion-seven-origin", "relation-assertion-skeptical-evaluation", "relation-assertion-three-coefficient-proposal", "relation-author-qualification", "relation-hegstrom-direct-rebuttal", "relation-lapakko-method-undercutting" ], "source_work_keys": [ "work-argyle-1970", "work-argyle-1971", "work-birmingham-events-page-2020", "work-hampshire-pcc-deck-2022", "work-hegstrom-1979", "work-lapakko-1997", "work-lapakko-2007", "work-mehrabian-author-page", "work-mehrabian-ferris-1967", "work-mehrabian-wiener-1967", "work-silent-messages" ], "span_keys": [ "span-argyle-1970-abstract", "span-argyle-1971-experiment-one", "span-argyle-1971-experiment-two", "span-author-equation", "span-author-qualification", "span-birmingham-generalization", "span-ferris-authors", "span-ferris-citation-p1", "span-ferris-design", "span-ferris-grants", "span-ferris-maybe", "span-ferris-models-speakers", "span-ferris-proposal", "span-ferris-regression", "span-ferris-sample", "span-ferris-scale", "span-ferris-sums-of-squares", "span-ferris-target", "span-hampshire-generalization", "span-hegstrom-design", "span-hegstrom-result", "span-lapakko-1997-abstract", "span-lapakko-2007-63-of-79", "span-lapakko-2007-abstract", "span-lapakko-2007-limitations", "span-silent-1971-boundary", "span-silent-1971-liking", "span-silent-1981-metadata", "span-wiener-authors", "span-wiener-ferris-acknowledgment", "span-wiener-grants", "span-wiener-instructions", "span-wiener-result-boundary", "span-wiener-safe-extension", "span-wiener-sample", "span-wiener-scale", "span-wiener-single-words", "span-wiener-speakers", "span-wiener-stimulus-recording", "span-wiener-target" ] }, "decision": "pass", "findings": [ { "severity": "material", "status": "resolved", "text": "The prior stale-base blocker is resolved by the normal two-parent merge successor. Current origin/main 700a822f38d00d13cc0661fd577bdb7e6e5b34dd is the reviewed base and an ancestor of the exact author head; every EM-0035 substantive blob is unchanged." }, { "severity": "informational", "status": "informational", "text": "The candidate preserves exact accepted EM-0033 packet, source-register, and independent-review bytes; 11 works, 12 editions, 40 spans, six calculations, five participant roots, 11 typed edges, three zero-credit propagation objects, and five follow-up dispositions close exactly." }, { "severity": "informational", "status": "informational", "text": "Encyclopedia and skeptical evaluations use the same source graph while producing materially distinct labels, reason codes, missing-derivation treatment, and reader upshots." } ], "format": "epistemedia-independent-dossier-review-v1", "git_state": { "fresh_clone": true, "post_review_clean": true, "post_review_head": "bc5e7ce87aa00d773ab9a3f1ec9b68a80c09957b", "pre_review_clean": true, "pre_review_head": "bc5e7ce87aa00d773ab9a3f1ec9b68a80c09957b", "unchanged_during_review": true }, "limitations": [ "The exact source derivation of the .07 coefficient remains unresolved and receives no credit; the reverse-engineering calculations are sensitivity analyses only.", "The 1981 edition is bibliographically identified but its formula pages remain uncollated against 1971.", "Closed or unavailable source text is not inferred beyond accepted quote-minimal spans, retrieval identities, access gaps, and license treatments.", "The bounded follow-up search is not exhaustive; propagation objects document circulation and receive zero scientific-rule evidence credit.", "This pass approves only the reversible research candidate receipt. It does not admit, feature, publish, promote, deploy, merge, or establish a universal law of communication." ], "repository": { "branch": "codex/em-0035-case004-dossier", "diff_sha256": "6feaa1d97a693819debdd44d1cf6f74db92783d7f55c256992278260bbb8b2f5", "pull_request": 60, "reviewed_author_head": "bc5e7ce87aa00d773ab9a3f1ec9b68a80c09957b", "reviewed_author_tree": "9988fa4e0b381db23f58d35e68d63c873eb4a122", "reviewed_base": "700a822f38d00d13cc0661fd577bdb7e6e5b34dd", "url": "https://github.com/yoheinakajima/epistemedia" }, "review_results": { "calculations": [ { "derivation_id": "derive-implied-vocal-verbal-ratio", "expected_result_sha256": "a384aadcd9e3dec5e0b09c41f18a5ec6d365b006296c044bd7e1f8592c15cd51", "observed_result_sha256": "a384aadcd9e3dec5e0b09c41f18a5ec6d365b006296c044bd7e1f8592c15cd51", "reproduced": true, "status": "pass" }, { "derivation_id": "derive-p2-allocation-with-seven-reserved", "expected_result_sha256": "83755fa489879266e59d8beccc1d27eea878aa47da658948a4a1d244f2fe87cc", "observed_result_sha256": "83755fa489879266e59d8beccc1d27eea878aa47da658948a4a1d244f2fe87cc", "reproduced": true, "status": "pass" }, { "derivation_id": "derive-p2-facial-vocal-ratio", "expected_result_sha256": "2285e5757b118b506875c31f7871b0258ebff677bb29382409ed98167675ae07", "observed_result_sha256": "2285e5757b118b506875c31f7871b0258ebff677bb29382409ed98167675ae07", "reproduced": true, "status": "pass" }, { "derivation_id": "derive-proposed-facial-vocal-ratio", "expected_result_sha256": "09e6e74dfde3024a8f7e9628f72ce899b3ab078ecaa189cf625ff5ed9677a2a9", "observed_result_sha256": "09e6e74dfde3024a8f7e9628f72ce899b3ab078ecaa189cf625ff5ed9677a2a9", "reproduced": true, "status": "pass" }, { "derivation_id": "derive-proposed-sum", "expected_result_sha256": "d0ff5974b6aa52cf562bea5921840c032a860a91a3512f7fe8f768f6bbe005f6", "observed_result_sha256": "d0ff5974b6aa52cf562bea5921840c032a860a91a3512f7fe8f768f6bbe005f6", "reproduced": true, "status": "pass" }, { "derivation_id": "derive-ratio-difference", "expected_result_sha256": "d02890db613586d87ab2b53e56460f83ba6a5fe24950437cfbc106b03d3f4663", "observed_result_sha256": "d02890db613586d87ab2b53e56460f83ba6a5fe24950437cfbc106b03d3f4663", "reproduced": true, "status": "pass" } ], "counts": { "expected_accepted_relation_counts": { "claims": 11, "derivations": 6, "follow_up_objects": 5, "lineage_edges": 11, "lineage_groups": 6, "participant_data_roots": 5, "propagation_objects": 3, "quote_minimal_spans": 40, "source_records": 12 }, "expected_dossier_counts": { "assertions": 20, "claim_families": 1, "editions": 12, "evaluations": 2, "evidence_relations": 35, "lineages": 23, "propositions": 20, "source_works": 11, "spans": 40 }, "observed_accepted_relation_counts": { "claims": 11, "derivations": 6, "follow_up_objects": 5, "lineage_edges": 11, "lineage_groups": 6, "participant_data_roots": 5, "propagation_objects": 3, "quote_minimal_spans": 40, "source_records": 12 }, "observed_dossier_counts": { "assertions": 20, "claim_families": 1, "editions": 12, "evaluations": 2, "evidence_relations": 35, "lineages": 23, "propositions": 20, "source_works": 11, "spans": 40 }, "relation_derived": true, "status": "pass" }, "evaluations": [ { "evaluation_key": "evaluation-encyclopedia", "materially_distinct_checked": true, "reason_codes": [ "historical-proposal-documented", "two-participant-roots-kept-distinct", "cross-study-integration-not-one-experiment", "scope-qualification-retained" ], "same_source_graph_checked": true, "source_graph_sha256": "e02032b582b7c0706b7498169653e98c190d27a692a8ef7ac8250b68628a28f8", "status": "pass" }, { "evaluation_key": "evaluation-skeptical", "materially_distinct_checked": true, "reason_codes": [ "no-reviewed-three-channel-test", "seven-percent-origin-unresolved", "direct-rebuttal-message-specific", "propagation-zero-truth-credit", "second-edition-formula-pages-uncollated" ], "same_source_graph_checked": true, "source_graph_sha256": "e02032b582b7c0706b7498169653e98c190d27a692a8ef7ac8250b68628a28f8", "status": "pass" } ], "lineages": [ { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-argyle-1970-abstract", "span-argyle-1971-experiment-one", "span-argyle-1971-experiment-two" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [ "lineage-participant-argyle-1970", "lineage-participant-argyle-1971" ], "lineage_key": "lineage-argyle-related-program", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-author-equation", "span-author-qualification" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [], "lineage_key": "lineage-author-qualification", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-birmingham-generalization" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [], "lineage_key": "lineage-birmingham-propagation", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-ferris-citation-p1", "span-ferris-design", "span-ferris-proposal", "span-ferris-regression" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [ "lineage-mehrabian-original-program" ], "lineage_key": "lineage-cross-study-proposal", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-argyle-1970-abstract", "span-argyle-1971-experiment-one", "span-argyle-1971-experiment-two", "span-hegstrom-design", "span-hegstrom-result", "span-lapakko-1997-abstract" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [ "lineage-argyle-related-program", "lineage-hegstrom-rebuttal", "lineage-lapakko-1997" ], "lineage_key": "lineage-follow-up-synthesis", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-argyle-1970-abstract", "span-argyle-1971-experiment-one", "span-argyle-1971-experiment-two", "span-author-equation", "span-author-qualification", "span-birmingham-generalization", "span-ferris-authors", "span-ferris-citation-p1", "span-ferris-design", "span-ferris-grants", "span-ferris-maybe", "span-ferris-models-speakers", "span-ferris-proposal", "span-ferris-regression", "span-ferris-sample", "span-ferris-scale", "span-ferris-sums-of-squares", "span-ferris-target", "span-hampshire-generalization", "span-hegstrom-design", "span-hegstrom-result", "span-lapakko-1997-abstract", "span-lapakko-2007-63-of-79", "span-lapakko-2007-abstract", "span-lapakko-2007-limitations", "span-silent-1971-boundary", "span-silent-1971-liking", "span-silent-1981-metadata", "span-wiener-authors", "span-wiener-ferris-acknowledgment", "span-wiener-grants", "span-wiener-instructions", "span-wiener-result-boundary", "span-wiener-safe-extension", "span-wiener-sample", "span-wiener-scale", "span-wiener-single-words", "span-wiener-speakers", "span-wiener-stimulus-recording", "span-wiener-target" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [ "lineage-argyle-related-program", "lineage-cross-study-proposal", "lineage-hegstrom-rebuttal", "lineage-mehrabian-interpretation", "lineage-propagation-synthesis" ], "lineage_key": "lineage-general-rule-synthesis", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-hampshire-generalization" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [], "lineage_key": "lineage-hampshire-propagation", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-hegstrom-design", "span-hegstrom-result" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [], "lineage_key": "lineage-hegstrom-rebuttal", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-birmingham-generalization", "span-hampshire-generalization" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [ "lineage-birmingham-propagation", "lineage-hampshire-propagation" ], "lineage_key": "lineage-institutional-recirculation", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-lapakko-1997-abstract" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [], "lineage_key": "lineage-lapakko-1997", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-lapakko-2007-63-of-79", "span-lapakko-2007-abstract", "span-lapakko-2007-limitations" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [], "lineage_key": "lineage-lapakko-2007", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-lapakko-1997-abstract", "span-lapakko-2007-63-of-79", "span-lapakko-2007-abstract", "span-lapakko-2007-limitations" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [ "lineage-lapakko-1997", "lineage-lapakko-2007" ], "lineage_key": "lineage-lapakko-critique-propagation", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-author-equation", "span-author-qualification", "span-silent-1971-boundary", "span-silent-1971-liking", "span-silent-1981-metadata" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [ "lineage-author-qualification", "lineage-silent-1971", "lineage-silent-1981-unknown" ], "lineage_key": "lineage-mehrabian-interpretation", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-ferris-authors", "span-ferris-citation-p1", "span-ferris-design", "span-ferris-grants", "span-ferris-maybe", "span-ferris-models-speakers", "span-ferris-proposal", "span-ferris-regression", "span-ferris-sample", "span-ferris-scale", "span-ferris-sums-of-squares", "span-ferris-target", "span-wiener-authors", "span-wiener-ferris-acknowledgment", "span-wiener-grants", "span-wiener-instructions", "span-wiener-result-boundary", "span-wiener-safe-extension", "span-wiener-sample", "span-wiener-scale", "span-wiener-single-words", "span-wiener-speakers", "span-wiener-stimulus-recording", "span-wiener-target" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [ "lineage-participant-p1", "lineage-participant-p2" ], "lineage_key": "lineage-mehrabian-original-program", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-argyle-1970-abstract" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [], "lineage_key": "lineage-participant-argyle-1970", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-argyle-1971-experiment-one", "span-argyle-1971-experiment-two" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [], "lineage_key": "lineage-participant-argyle-1971", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-wiener-authors", "span-wiener-ferris-acknowledgment", "span-wiener-grants", "span-wiener-instructions", "span-wiener-result-boundary", "span-wiener-safe-extension", "span-wiener-sample", "span-wiener-scale", "span-wiener-single-words", "span-wiener-speakers", "span-wiener-stimulus-recording", "span-wiener-target" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [], "lineage_key": "lineage-participant-p1", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-ferris-authors", "span-ferris-citation-p1", "span-ferris-design", "span-ferris-grants", "span-ferris-maybe", "span-ferris-models-speakers", "span-ferris-proposal", "span-ferris-regression", "span-ferris-sample", "span-ferris-scale", "span-ferris-sums-of-squares", "span-ferris-target" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [], "lineage_key": "lineage-participant-p2", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-birmingham-generalization", "span-hampshire-generalization", "span-lapakko-2007-63-of-79", "span-lapakko-2007-abstract", "span-lapakko-2007-limitations" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [ "lineage-institutional-recirculation", "lineage-lapakko-critique-propagation" ], "lineage_key": "lineage-propagation-synthesis", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-argyle-1970-abstract", "span-argyle-1971-experiment-one", "span-argyle-1971-experiment-two", "span-author-equation", "span-author-qualification", "span-birmingham-generalization", "span-ferris-authors", "span-ferris-citation-p1", "span-ferris-design", "span-ferris-grants", "span-ferris-maybe", "span-ferris-models-speakers", "span-ferris-proposal", "span-ferris-regression", "span-ferris-sample", "span-ferris-scale", "span-ferris-sums-of-squares", "span-ferris-target", "span-hampshire-generalization", "span-hegstrom-design", "span-hegstrom-result", "span-lapakko-1997-abstract", "span-lapakko-2007-63-of-79", "span-lapakko-2007-abstract", "span-lapakko-2007-limitations", "span-silent-1971-boundary", "span-silent-1971-liking", "span-silent-1981-metadata", "span-wiener-authors", "span-wiener-ferris-acknowledgment", "span-wiener-grants", "span-wiener-instructions", "span-wiener-result-boundary", "span-wiener-safe-extension", "span-wiener-sample", "span-wiener-scale", "span-wiener-single-words", "span-wiener-speakers", "span-wiener-stimulus-recording", "span-wiener-target" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [ "lineage-argyle-related-program", "lineage-hegstrom-rebuttal", "lineage-institutional-recirculation", "lineage-lapakko-critique-propagation", "lineage-mehrabian-interpretation", "lineage-mehrabian-original-program" ], "lineage_key": "lineage-reviewed-source-register", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-ferris-proposal", "span-ferris-regression", "span-silent-1971-liking" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [ "lineage-cross-study-proposal" ], "lineage_key": "lineage-seven-origin-unknown", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-silent-1971-boundary", "span-silent-1971-liking" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [], "lineage_key": "lineage-silent-1971", "status": "pass" }, { "basis_span_keys": [ "span-silent-1981-metadata" ], "dependence_checked": true, "depends_on": [], "lineage_key": "lineage-silent-1981-unknown", "status": "pass" } ], "propositions": [ { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-1981-edition" ], "proposition_key": "claim-1981-edition", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-1981-edition" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-author-qualification", "span-silent-1981-metadata" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-book-boundary" ], "proposition_key": "claim-book-boundary", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-book-boundary" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-silent-1971-boundary", "span-silent-1971-liking" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-hegstrom-rebuttal" ], "proposition_key": "claim-hegstrom-rebuttal", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-hegstrom-rebuttal" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-hegstrom-design", "span-hegstrom-result" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-p1-tone-dominance" ], "proposition_key": "claim-p1-tone-dominance", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-p1-tone-dominance" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-wiener-result-boundary", "span-wiener-safe-extension", "span-wiener-single-words" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-p2-face-tone" ], "proposition_key": "claim-p2-face-tone", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-p2-face-tone" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-ferris-design", "span-ferris-maybe", "span-ferris-regression", "span-ferris-sums-of-squares" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-popular-rule" ], "proposition_key": "claim-popular-rule", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-popular-rule", "relation-author-qualification", "relation-hegstrom-direct-rebuttal", "relation-lapakko-method-undercutting" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-author-qualification", "span-ferris-target", "span-hegstrom-result", "span-wiener-target" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-propagation" ], "proposition_key": "claim-propagation", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-propagation" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-birmingham-generalization", "span-hampshire-generalization", "span-lapakko-2007-63-of-79", "span-lapakko-2007-limitations" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-related-context" ], "proposition_key": "claim-related-context", "relation_keys": [ "relation-argyle-context-qualification", "relation-assertion-related-context" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-argyle-1970-abstract", "span-argyle-1971-experiment-one", "span-argyle-1971-experiment-two" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-replication-search" ], "proposition_key": "claim-replication-search", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-replication-search" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-argyle-1971-experiment-two", "span-hegstrom-result", "span-lapakko-1997-abstract" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-seven-origin" ], "proposition_key": "claim-seven-origin", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-seven-origin" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-ferris-proposal", "span-ferris-regression", "span-silent-1971-liking" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-three-coefficient-proposal" ], "proposition_key": "claim-three-coefficient-proposal", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-three-coefficient-proposal" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-ferris-design", "span-ferris-proposal", "span-ferris-target" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-derive-implied-vocal-verbal-ratio" ], "proposition_key": "derive-implied-vocal-verbal-ratio", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-derive-implied-vocal-verbal-ratio" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-ferris-proposal" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-derive-p2-allocation-with-seven-reserved" ], "proposition_key": "derive-p2-allocation-with-seven-reserved", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-derive-p2-allocation-with-seven-reserved" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-ferris-proposal", "span-ferris-regression" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-derive-p2-facial-vocal-ratio" ], "proposition_key": "derive-p2-facial-vocal-ratio", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-derive-p2-facial-vocal-ratio" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-ferris-regression" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-derive-proposed-facial-vocal-ratio" ], "proposition_key": "derive-proposed-facial-vocal-ratio", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-derive-proposed-facial-vocal-ratio" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-ferris-proposal" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-derive-proposed-sum" ], "proposition_key": "derive-proposed-sum", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-derive-proposed-sum" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-ferris-proposal" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-derive-ratio-difference" ], "proposition_key": "derive-ratio-difference", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-derive-ratio-difference" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-ferris-proposal", "span-ferris-regression" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-encyclopedia-evaluation" ], "proposition_key": "prop-encyclopedia-evaluation", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-encyclopedia-evaluation" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-author-qualification", "span-ferris-design", "span-ferris-proposal", "span-ferris-target", "span-silent-1971-boundary", "span-wiener-target" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-reviewed-source-register" ], "proposition_key": "prop-reviewed-source-register", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-reviewed-source-register" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-argyle-1970-abstract", "span-argyle-1971-experiment-one", "span-argyle-1971-experiment-two", "span-author-equation", "span-author-qualification", "span-birmingham-generalization", "span-ferris-authors", "span-ferris-citation-p1", "span-ferris-design", "span-ferris-grants", "span-ferris-maybe", "span-ferris-models-speakers", "span-ferris-proposal", "span-ferris-regression", "span-ferris-sample", "span-ferris-scale", "span-ferris-sums-of-squares", "span-ferris-target", "span-hampshire-generalization", "span-hegstrom-design", "span-hegstrom-result", "span-lapakko-1997-abstract", "span-lapakko-2007-63-of-79", "span-lapakko-2007-abstract", "span-lapakko-2007-limitations", "span-silent-1971-boundary", "span-silent-1971-liking", "span-silent-1981-metadata", "span-wiener-authors", "span-wiener-ferris-acknowledgment", "span-wiener-grants", "span-wiener-instructions", "span-wiener-result-boundary", "span-wiener-safe-extension", "span-wiener-sample", "span-wiener-scale", "span-wiener-single-words", "span-wiener-speakers", "span-wiener-stimulus-recording", "span-wiener-target" ], "status": "pass" }, { "assertion_keys": [ "assertion-skeptical-evaluation" ], "proposition_key": "prop-skeptical-evaluation", "relation_keys": [ "relation-assertion-skeptical-evaluation" ], "sentence_closure_checked": true, "span_keys": [ "span-ferris-design", "span-ferris-proposal", "span-ferris-target", "span-hegstrom-result", "span-lapakko-1997-abstract", "span-wiener-target" ], "status": "pass" } ], "sources": [ { "access_and_gap_checked": true, "capture_ids": [ "capture-argyle-1970-crossref-20260827" ], "edition_key": "edition-argyle-bjscp-9-3", "identity_checked": true, "license_treatment_checked": true, "source_id": "source-argyle-1970", "span_keys": [ "span-argyle-1970-abstract" ], "status": "pass", "work_key": "work-argyle-1970" }, { "access_and_gap_checked": true, "capture_ids": [ "capture-argyle-1971-crossref-20260827" ], "edition_key": "edition-argyle-ejsp-1-3", "identity_checked": true, "license_treatment_checked": true, "source_id": "source-argyle-1971", "span_keys": [ "span-argyle-1971-experiment-one", "span-argyle-1971-experiment-two" ], "status": "pass", "work_key": "work-argyle-1971" }, { "access_and_gap_checked": true, "capture_ids": [ "capture-birmingham-20260827" ], "edition_key": "edition-birmingham-events-20260827", "identity_checked": true, "license_treatment_checked": true, "source_id": "source-birmingham-events-2020", "span_keys": [ "span-birmingham-generalization" ], "status": "pass", "work_key": "work-birmingham-events-page-2020" }, { "access_and_gap_checked": true, "capture_ids": [ "capture-hampshire-20260827" ], "edition_key": "edition-hampshire-pcc-master-010322", "identity_checked": true, "license_treatment_checked": true, "source_id": "source-hampshire-pcc-2022", "span_keys": [ "span-hampshire-generalization" ], "status": "pass", "work_key": "work-hampshire-pcc-deck-2022" }, { "access_and_gap_checked": true, "capture_ids": [ "capture-hegstrom-crossref-20260827", "capture-hegstrom-eric-20260827" ], "edition_key": "edition-hegstrom-wjsc-43-2", "identity_checked": true, "license_treatment_checked": true, "source_id": "source-hegstrom-1979", "span_keys": [ "span-hegstrom-design", "span-hegstrom-result" ], "status": "pass", "work_key": "work-hegstrom-1979" }, { "access_and_gap_checked": true, "capture_ids": [ "capture-lapakko-1997-crossref-20260827", "capture-lapakko-1997-eric-20260827" ], "edition_key": "edition-lapakko-communication-education-46-1", "identity_checked": true, "license_treatment_checked": true, "source_id": "source-lapakko-1997", "span_keys": [ "span-lapakko-1997-abstract" ], "status": "pass", "work_key": "work-lapakko-1997" }, { "access_and_gap_checked": true, "capture_ids": [ "capture-lapakko-2007-crossref-20260827", "capture-lapakko-2007-landing-20260827", "readback-lapakko-2007-pdf-20260827" ], "edition_key": "edition-ctamj-volume-34-article-2", "identity_checked": true, "license_treatment_checked": true, "source_id": "source-lapakko-2007", "span_keys": [ "span-lapakko-2007-63-of-79", "span-lapakko-2007-abstract", "span-lapakko-2007-limitations" ], "status": "pass", "work_key": "work-lapakko-2007" }, { "access_and_gap_checked": true, "capture_ids": [ "capture-author-page-20260827" ], "edition_key": "edition-kaaj-silent-messages-page-2016", "identity_checked": true, "license_treatment_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-author-qualification", "span_keys": [ "span-author-equation", "span-author-qualification" ], "status": "pass", "work_key": "work-mehrabian-author-page" }, { "access_and_gap_checked": true, "capture_ids": [ "capture-ferris-crossref-20260823", "capture-ferris-openalex-20260827", "capture-ferris-pubmed-20260827", "capture-ferris-scan-20260823" ], "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-ferris-jcp-31-3", "identity_checked": true, "license_treatment_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-ferris-1967", "span_keys": [ "span-ferris-authors", "span-ferris-citation-p1", "span-ferris-design", "span-ferris-grants", "span-ferris-maybe", "span-ferris-models-speakers", "span-ferris-proposal", "span-ferris-regression", "span-ferris-sample", "span-ferris-scale", "span-ferris-sums-of-squares", "span-ferris-target" ], "status": "pass", "work_key": "work-mehrabian-ferris-1967" }, { "access_and_gap_checked": true, "capture_ids": [ "capture-wiener-crossref-20260827", "capture-wiener-openalex-20260827", "capture-wiener-pubmed-20260827", "capture-wiener-scan-20260823" ], "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-wiener-jpsp-6-1", "identity_checked": true, "license_treatment_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-wiener-1967", "span_keys": [ "span-wiener-authors", "span-wiener-ferris-acknowledgment", "span-wiener-grants", "span-wiener-instructions", "span-wiener-result-boundary", "span-wiener-safe-extension", "span-wiener-sample", "span-wiener-scale", "span-wiener-single-words", "span-wiener-speakers", "span-wiener-stimulus-recording", "span-wiener-target" ], "status": "pass", "work_key": "work-mehrabian-wiener-1967" }, { "access_and_gap_checked": true, "capture_ids": [ "capture-silent-1971-openlibrary-20260823", "capture-silent-1971-scan-20260827" ], "edition_key": "edition-silent-messages-1971", "identity_checked": true, "license_treatment_checked": true, "source_id": "source-silent-messages-1971", "span_keys": [ "span-silent-1971-boundary", "span-silent-1971-liking" ], "status": "pass", "work_key": "work-silent-messages" }, { "access_and_gap_checked": true, "capture_ids": [ "capture-silent-1981-openlibrary-20260827" ], "edition_key": "edition-silent-messages-1981-second", "identity_checked": true, "license_treatment_checked": true, "source_id": "source-silent-messages-1981", "span_keys": [ "span-silent-1981-metadata" ], "status": "pass", "work_key": "work-silent-messages" } ], "spans": [ { "edition_key": "edition-argyle-bjscp-9-3", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:75bb9f2b9bf5c6dbfd26a2628aabf677e631ba9851ef607aa6006b9c499b2feb", "quote_sha256": "1c646e683fa1fae891328ff0aa173a6819a4bffdaa3d85b14ab35d321fc51fce", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-argyle-1970", "span_key": "span-argyle-1970-abstract", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-argyle-ejsp-1-3", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:ae9e89c0355eac4c1f6c10e9e29b25e97a98e5566ad0b931ce3a56ce205c6b3e", "quote_sha256": "0cf68d8b04488ee2dae7795e58ef3204eda6ea25a69ab0e8aa9799cf324d821b", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-argyle-1971", "span_key": "span-argyle-1971-experiment-one", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-argyle-ejsp-1-3", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:802725074f3cf29bb7df2595a197a41006f302dbd070f4c1d5fd69377199e637", "quote_sha256": "02f4d3fdaf74b293076b3521515a54d6968638aaa4882fc9a3f25c4a7442333f", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-argyle-1971", "span_key": "span-argyle-1971-experiment-two", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-kaaj-silent-messages-page-2016", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:832b8feda03ef4145d2bf313d051aff44e8b33c22da11ab0060787d2a76fc11d", "quote_sha256": "f74af100fbb21524c77c32d9d52a14dc6ff661fbb6685402365363ca1f532738", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-author-qualification", "span_key": "span-author-equation", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-kaaj-silent-messages-page-2016", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:17fc31577e9efe03e26b79276749e7a724ffbe134ac1af41b51c1fe9d227a8cf", "quote_sha256": "b177c97d10c09f52d123b7b2eb3577bd07cfc84d3f5954140f1d64045e463611", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-author-qualification", "span_key": "span-author-qualification", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-birmingham-events-20260827", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:7fadc1793ce8dc246fc58b2adb489786eb264a422fc20c06b27264600e4121f9", "quote_sha256": "efbc0d7cb80da147fd0c043ea73dd348b337b0d44281ff3144588a0788f71ff9", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-birmingham-events-2020", "span_key": "span-birmingham-generalization", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-ferris-jcp-31-3", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:6a7e1b46e0d8c84cc99ec4889d9f6a1fb59f27b705bd51b8c1fa4044e9e191f8", "quote_sha256": "ccbbe41f1e4ec76d7d14620f62caa2af412b1b8228fccdbf0ae43062408d35f7", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-ferris-1967", "span_key": "span-ferris-authors", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-ferris-jcp-31-3", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:1c8f1af0b30bdd33c03329bd4415d9e1a7f590dc0ae1fe778473c47a23b00cff", "quote_sha256": "c25471b821ce495d1763c8f398825a939f67fb6856a2cef7f162fe6416d87912", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-ferris-1967", "span_key": "span-ferris-citation-p1", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-ferris-jcp-31-3", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:fa09f76126dae7eb46c331df6ffa7f8b671f4002a64646ace7e448d80e3562d0", "quote_sha256": "4907fba561fdbd65d1135094c20e780a5813d5d27bc111a8d02440833a7acb30", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-ferris-1967", "span_key": "span-ferris-design", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-ferris-jcp-31-3", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:0b97104409c92a83ff20e4b1081be0327d582e54f24d5262b4c31b24f6cb4979", "quote_sha256": "cda7dfc2f1ed1632a34e92b220fca7788184c09ddb0016ce23fbfba056e2cfe2", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-ferris-1967", "span_key": "span-ferris-grants", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-ferris-jcp-31-3", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:8dedb954a92c8050788780fd9b97a9f29f72707bc9eaa648e2972943501890cc", "quote_sha256": "56c335cc10ba6cd0b1e00bbb4571a1fea45c4b9abde580f86093310dcc9f121e", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-ferris-1967", "span_key": "span-ferris-maybe", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-ferris-jcp-31-3", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:293aedc5af3fab7f7cc039d6cd4f24333e135b2923d09ccd300b9389374ffb79", "quote_sha256": "f2c2c6a9095ce271eb0842c7b7268bfc09c732405f448a928ee4876b2eeed48b", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-ferris-1967", "span_key": "span-ferris-models-speakers", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-ferris-jcp-31-3", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:53ed12503f6f297e17aa6a73173f5c32fc5fc44b686048639e6acb0cd900ec9e", "quote_sha256": "25b2e2dcf6675d0e73fd204bb0e6303caa18f2fe5d9d6df5c7dea105cf49a50f", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-ferris-1967", "span_key": "span-ferris-proposal", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-ferris-jcp-31-3", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:bcc0eade411f9c8c396c9b9fcdba75229f47d89257a82c908cb4cf7e98c0ce49", "quote_sha256": "7cf8e54d2b0fddc90a956178f67bb65ec005d41bb9b1c17e676e92458fbbf692", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-ferris-1967", "span_key": "span-ferris-regression", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-ferris-jcp-31-3", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:af3ea87f2d7d460331048afbea8bed571db8d1b7bfc9b88f9dfae16eac02a87b", "quote_sha256": "3a4983215b94a8f7a35dfc1867bd6c435a3cd2b380bc8e9986a711c731452528", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-ferris-1967", "span_key": "span-ferris-sample", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-ferris-jcp-31-3", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:0e3dcdaf6984a8b118d93a236e025bcd1f565e61b41a823b9a14002f004b16cf", "quote_sha256": "f75aae955db7d8f43645cdf9892aed90b48c9b02e6316dfc342219ae3dc82b47", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-ferris-1967", "span_key": "span-ferris-scale", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-ferris-jcp-31-3", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:8aa2729b7ef029023794395a31dbd45ec393ce5d06c7ba93f10d67ca31120f1e", "quote_sha256": "bd118404b90041fbbb3c264018163e4b4c03db1d33c6a4b007360d6387845b4d", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-ferris-1967", "span_key": "span-ferris-sums-of-squares", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-ferris-jcp-31-3", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:220db2149c0f0244a0e43b6bfeb4d941396a6783121b071b799f69cd8ebe0704", "quote_sha256": "0a55d590acd009bec93e34c67f9c4b528154411b32575493cb9f9fde2b41924c", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-ferris-1967", "span_key": "span-ferris-target", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-hampshire-pcc-master-010322", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:a93da9a7d23a8c4493fc2fd09a983c5aa6a75dff91861bf528a6408478782e1b", "quote_sha256": "88c8a056a68b7c5e737a5bdee82c65e6bf1e68002df30fc04961d7acf5b7a2ec", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-hampshire-pcc-2022", "span_key": "span-hampshire-generalization", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-hegstrom-wjsc-43-2", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:9940e90fe3daa217ffb54ae30f060049767ba1dd0b3cee7af122a5e2afa7850f", "quote_sha256": "6a5cf9079b86b76fe5c7cbc41c1cf69ee015b2537e6bccc0fbccfef3ec4b992e", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-hegstrom-1979", "span_key": "span-hegstrom-design", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-hegstrom-wjsc-43-2", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:8984ae9eb204a78ae87c6bf2e367d74699e49a53e0892ada7d3d93c25bdb8873", "quote_sha256": "a05c496c590dbd519f345528c97b7badf4b1888fbdeb59952a7c24ad0d69af96", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-hegstrom-1979", "span_key": "span-hegstrom-result", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-lapakko-communication-education-46-1", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:66eee82a6f2ee78c7193b781786c02a3bc883bf69a9f8d3fcc58d0fb3e295d12", "quote_sha256": "e62ce29580268d0767bdfd1fd1e87898381c16c05cc97f789ea19e464b025fc6", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-lapakko-1997", "span_key": "span-lapakko-1997-abstract", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-ctamj-volume-34-article-2", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:95dcb11743dc3084a82159fda3d90e35b0c1e5416989283d770ce4540ffa577c", "quote_sha256": "d40f9be8d74579dc4b55180886d0eb17374f260e487bba97bc5a676a1a197c42", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-lapakko-2007", "span_key": "span-lapakko-2007-63-of-79", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-ctamj-volume-34-article-2", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:fc269da48a2344a2ef5ca68062d89d49ed6bd6391ad965d2e757b5b405d6c169", "quote_sha256": "a712f31a787c456e3d1693cba28b62ec4d4a6f14db9d196176671f15fa66efd3", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-lapakko-2007", "span_key": "span-lapakko-2007-abstract", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-ctamj-volume-34-article-2", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:054513e403862a7e7b9092d7667ceb4d3be303365d08cba9ae4e5e5ba2f72d34", "quote_sha256": "fc3c646bac3611993037d02aa42b56b0c374b8c2ea99260859d36aa057bc4231", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-lapakko-2007", "span_key": "span-lapakko-2007-limitations", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-silent-messages-1971", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:d221b89ba1ec0a6ebcfbe0ddd9db1a5033e2aa40adc3b488e99363f03e7314d0", "quote_sha256": "f42ea8e4be606d422d7b6ab9495c3b03ad812d953dff3034ef07b5fa66613201", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-silent-messages-1971", "span_key": "span-silent-1971-boundary", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-silent-messages-1971", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:ff46a19ba7348d36caf9e749bc427e19b1e00e89ed5306d3c01c2533d10cd6b3", "quote_sha256": "b64646d71e22e4e9508d73d3b4896301ebf38472816e0002115a9ceea44e8f22", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-silent-messages-1971", "span_key": "span-silent-1971-liking", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-silent-messages-1981-second", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:0aea216641f6e03efd85523e296cf7339572d5d5844d646f347fc6d31f1ebb4e", "quote_sha256": "3520c0ef2afb95d687d9a61df564ccc1105381c6fab8a6ff5954779f3466dd2b", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-silent-messages-1981", "span_key": "span-silent-1981-metadata", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-wiener-jpsp-6-1", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:82edc478aaf90f7256ef12983d8990ba351b4c2cbf89995d2a3fa2de4a02f145", "quote_sha256": "9f86c9e0e9a0912dc98e89492e403b3604c93a4c4b291594c31b9dff098be20d", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-wiener-1967", "span_key": "span-wiener-authors", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-wiener-jpsp-6-1", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:fea4c8c77dc0c21357695d68cf2d92d67df47b1f334204aa3dd395d91484ef9d", "quote_sha256": "400ac8d3f7b66282787262afc078cb26a6b8090d7d1b3d9cc1cbafd2ba590e21", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-wiener-1967", "span_key": "span-wiener-ferris-acknowledgment", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-wiener-jpsp-6-1", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:a81c4e8fa7026bc0ef68acf15fb71839eef2be533dd7dab4e83850248221b50c", "quote_sha256": "f36d310eb93d14dc5a0d0761bcfd5196da637264c310574f76c7c212cb7efadb", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-wiener-1967", "span_key": "span-wiener-grants", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-wiener-jpsp-6-1", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:fef166170b36d45130767891e6bf19f537f3f0a5f1eac1be055ea4175f902ceb", "quote_sha256": "4cb1102a04af97ed38d0a2e7c205dfad7deb5844a79d106d05259cf7ac9f30c3", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-wiener-1967", "span_key": "span-wiener-instructions", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-wiener-jpsp-6-1", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:761cfd2bd83d57abecdecadb7b987c615cabdfddd72703381ca1b903d19c3255", "quote_sha256": "24b4829f5b2eea31c281bba86db573262bea45e6250c8beedd675b8f9a45db40", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-wiener-1967", "span_key": "span-wiener-result-boundary", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-wiener-jpsp-6-1", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:1f66fc733072a9927de032b62f0b5e96dfc6658513120e232169865b2e12e27d", "quote_sha256": "9c4d9597c61175b0e6ced4918ddea51d3aeb53df8e555780d626172e992cc68b", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-wiener-1967", "span_key": "span-wiener-safe-extension", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-wiener-jpsp-6-1", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:0eefeb725dcdcbcc3628a841cdf4645e01c2f93be5e7639b1560110a915e6149", "quote_sha256": "4b7b80fe130fafffae5829f4d71f7bb0dd795103ea0d0601c019d77b648efd80", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-wiener-1967", "span_key": "span-wiener-sample", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-wiener-jpsp-6-1", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:295def92855616c9cfcbccf976f9f93e1f1ccc76cfc3d42d06ba78ec063dd5a7", "quote_sha256": "79a892503102e31330c91f06aff865e9c50794cef6a8708a11145d8e616630a9", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-wiener-1967", "span_key": "span-wiener-scale", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-wiener-jpsp-6-1", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:878d98c8f706d93d8e5daa466feb939c9f0bc4fcd886900ba55ee416543a78b3", "quote_sha256": "488d310c64fb4445de8193a17dce78b0fe41533b54446429038687fa082b1e97", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-wiener-1967", "span_key": "span-wiener-single-words", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-wiener-jpsp-6-1", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:a8cdaf1a34a0999bed915a34ce580ce4aa7fec551948b82641b04230cc09427d", "quote_sha256": "5fe2933c7f2a1e18b24f4421d9dd0180582f30887cd123618fe848945db1a85a", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-wiener-1967", "span_key": "span-wiener-speakers", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-wiener-jpsp-6-1", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:27df3aca72c5cc9ea017067ac17a7932a37dd2cc10b9f38164fb2f301e873650", "quote_sha256": "d0fd2ff6d09434d59506dd8baa65db231331bca622f7a360cb8d26bf10ac0f59", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-wiener-1967", "span_key": "span-wiener-stimulus-recording", "status": "pass" }, { "edition_key": "edition-mehrabian-wiener-jpsp-6-1", "license_treatment_checked": true, "locator_checked": true, "parent_span_digest": "sha256:e5a5e1ffb2ebed6cd6dc939f4ec23d4e956df40f5b5e12b187296c72ec8a24fd", "quote_sha256": "32365cd2cac9626ee55ebdea19048ae1a2b9b70801559c91a3b26916b5d0c108", "retrieval_identity_checked": true, "segment_or_field_checked": true, "source_id": "source-mehrabian-wiener-1967", "span_key": "span-wiener-target", "status": "pass" } ] }, "reviewer": { "author_agent_id": "codex-em0035-author", "authoring_notes_used_as_evidence": false, "fresh_clone": true, "id": "codex-independent-em0035-reviewer", "notes": "Fresh independent clone and exact-head successor review. The normal merge successor was byte-identical to the fully audited author content across every research and documentation path; accepted EM-0033 evidence and the dossier were revalidated from repository bytes. Authoring notes were not used as evidence.", "reviewer_was_author": false, "role": "independent-reviewer" }, "started_at": "2026-08-28T00:17:30Z", "task_id": "EM-0035" }