# Independent Em0029 Review Receipt

- Object ID: `em:research-note:sha256:1e351b1c71ad24648ef7e530acdd47c9db69199f34a6c5154dfe74da269d74f5`
- Kind: `research-note`
- Repository path: [`research/how-we-know/agent-citation-lineage/independent-em0029-review-receipt.json`](https://github.com/yoheinakajima/epistemedia/blob/f92846570180dfa4511263f8ba98ecd18f7772c9/research/how-we-know/agent-citation-lineage/independent-em0029-review-receipt.json)
- Content digest: `dd7f8ad5f760137d91346c3bf38b2bbfffbc7e5c2e74a8a987b76d857e4f244e`

**Also filed under:** [Research Program](https://epistemedia.org/topics/research-program/)

## Source content

{
  "schema": "https://epistemedia.org/research/independent-review-receipt-v1.json",
  "task_id": "EM-0029",
  "run_id": "em0029-exact-author-head-independent-review-20260824T071850Z",
  "status": "passed-independent-review-exact-author-head",
  "decision": "pass",
  "reviewer": "codex-independent-em0029-reviewer",
  "independence_statement": "Reviewed in a fresh bounded clone without accepting author conclusions as evidence. The review rebound the exact base, author head, tree, dossier, supplement, accepted EM-0026 packet, public-edition identities, exact spans, count grammar, dependence semantics, disclosures, and deterministic gates. The three review supplements were checked against retained credential-free bytes of the same accepted public editions. No exploratory research, agent run, provider call, credential use, or spend occurred.",
  "completed_at": "2026-08-24T07:18:50Z",
  "repository": {
    "url": "https://github.com/yoheinakajima/epistemedia",
    "pull_request": 52,
    "branch": "codex/em-0029-case002-dossier",
    "reviewed_base": "75f01214750e9eccc4235cbe2a56eada1c014168",
    "reviewed_failed_predecessor_head": "89ca2aefbaad6501545c00ac9aa9ba0c3454cd25",
    "reviewed_author_head": "16b8e8ebc26948f8d9fa86120c3d495bca3f74e9",
    "reviewed_author_tree": "15fbd7c854ab5cbaed49ab6b47a70d0bd3cdf82f",
    "successor_relation": "exactly-one-forward-child"
  },
  "github_author_head_ci": {
    "workflow": "validate",
    "run_id": 32700574755,
    "job_id": 97351078241,
    "head": "16b8e8ebc26948f8d9fa86120c3d495bca3f74e9",
    "conclusion": "success"
  },
  "candidate_dossier": {
    "path": "research/how-we-know/agent-citation-lineage/candidate-dossier.json",
    "id": "em:dossier:sha256:cbd7a14096a956f642f5c76046d3b49ed648fbe6bf24144c992404a01415af82",
    "sha256": "1ae06b54fe6c6ce1803836bbf2ecaf3e652bed2c6878b7e095c01a1c689ab87b",
    "bytes": 483595,
    "stage": "draft"
  },
  "review_supplement": {
    "path": "research/how-we-know/agent-citation-lineage/review-supplement-spans-v1.json",
    "sha256": "7daa7d56cf42f764448235074cf4e87abb81d4f3a99d16dae063b844dc6aa6c0",
    "bytes": 3021,
    "span_count": 3,
    "accepted_em0026_exact_span_roots": 72,
    "credit_treatment": "qualification-only; excluded from the accepted EM-0026 exact-span-root count and from evidentiary warrant credit",
    "records": [
      {
        "supplement_id": "supplement:deeptrace-gemini-table-50-3",
        "warrant_id": "warrant:deeptrace-support-variation",
        "edition_id": "edition:deeptrace-iclr-2026",
        "carrier_sha256": "dea4981c1066d0240a005f603b3b14419c7e32beb5191b3df847ceb26af3d6b6",
        "carrier_bytes": 2982839,
        "locator": "printed page 9; physical PDF page 9 of 22; Table 1; Gemini (DR) column; %Citation Accuracy row",
        "extent": {
          "row": "%Citation Accuracy",
          "column": "Gemini (DR)",
          "cell": "50.3"
        },
        "containment": "pass"
      },
      {
        "supplement_id": "supplement:deeptrace-gemini-prose-40-3",
        "warrant_id": "warrant:deeptrace-support-variation",
        "edition_id": "edition:deeptrace-iclr-2026",
        "carrier_sha256": "dea4981c1066d0240a005f603b3b14419c7e32beb5191b3df847ceb26af3d6b6",
        "carrier_bytes": 2982839,
        "locator": "printed page 10; physical PDF page 10 of 22; Section 4 Results; Deep Research Agents paragraph",
        "extent": "Gemini(DR) demonstrates weak citation performance: only 40.3% citation accuracy",
        "containment": "pass"
      },
      {
        "supplement_id": "supplement:url-health-drbench-precollected-outputs",
        "warrant_id": "warrant:url-health-resolution",
        "edition_id": "edition:url-health-arxiv-v1",
        "carrier_sha256": "332e5b5cb4b0ee7065b1bbc30436dfdfeafca8130fb87e32b0020026d8bbafe1",
        "carrier_bytes": 302498,
        "locator": "Section 3.1 Datasets; section#S3.SS1; paragraph p#S3.SS1.p1.1",
        "extent": "DRBench (17) comprises 100 multilingual research queries (Chinese and English) covering finance, science, and technology, with pre-collected outputs from 23 models.",
        "containment": "pass"
      }
    ]
  },
  "accepted_em0026_packet": {
    "comparison_base": "75f01214750e9eccc4235cbe2a56eada1c014168",
    "result": "byte-identical",
    "objects": {
      "answers-v2": "git-tree:0abc7b83a7a3dbef638ee210419af024f2fbf4e8",
      "traces-v2": "git-tree:0f91e638884c44ee9e6e8bfab43603df3518535d",
      "source-readbacks-v1.json": "git-blob:ecfd887285a7bf79bc106465ee4344cdec5e6d5c",
      "span-readbacks-v1.json": "git-blob:49706a0973ecc0f0877bda58227362095fa0c10b",
      "source-normalization-v1.json": "git-blob:c292c8c68d746428447fbcf73a8219602f4ddcec",
      "evidence-ledger-v1.json": "git-blob:20e5c555fcf49f9cd892b3b97155fb3f1a12797e",
      "author-review-receipt.json": "git-blob:f1eb414fef97ee3bb4f72c5b377cb4fc9f8fad74",
      "independent-review-receipt.json": "git-blob:80ff483a4f54a8719caab358d05b2023c790a270"
    }
  },
  "source_identity_review": {
    "result": "pass",
    "credential_free": true,
    "examined_source_work_count": 11,
    "examined_edition_count": 14,
    "edition_identities": [
      {
        "key": "edition-citation-verifier-arxiv-v1-acfd4abab7",
        "id": "em:dossier-edition:sha256:11f00fc6576322cec62671d5ff7dec3c0c9bed06c139e6f704054259b06241c4",
        "canonical_url": "https://arxiv.org/html/2607.08700v1",
        "license": "CC BY 4.0"
      },
      {
        "key": "edition-cnv-arxiv-v1-f24001c50a",
        "id": "em:dossier-edition:sha256:601f0e4510819607265b94c8261884c072d559e63de9f71dbfc6bca5d33c5e29",
        "canonical_url": "https://arxiv.org/html/2605.06635v1",
        "license": "CC BY 4.0"
      },
      {
        "key": "edition-deeptrace-arxiv-v1-70a6e720c1",
        "id": "em:dossier-edition:sha256:c7779c770aa24aa5925b5fe6e66f968c733e8522d30bcdc4290bc9409bbe8b5b",
        "canonical_url": "https://arxiv.org/html/2509.04499v1",
        "license": "arXiv non-exclusive distribution license"
      },
      {
        "key": "edition-deeptrace-iclr-2026-b2b153eaa6",
        "id": "em:dossier-edition:sha256:1a587168a59e161ea083b7b289339c5f41444a26f2f82a2eb8acb43b27367f70",
        "canonical_url": "https://proceedings.iclr.cc/paper_files/paper/2026/file/ad08767706825033b99122332293033d-Paper-Conference.pdf",
        "license": "unknown"
      },
      {
        "key": "edition-drbench-arxiv-v1-7afa5ade36",
        "id": "em:dossier-edition:sha256:c0f1d83abed0c9adcc86259b5bfe38e3f18b290f25227b5b9e77c99322fe0b2c",
        "canonical_url": "https://arxiv.org/html/2506.11763v1",
        "license": "CC BY 4.0"
      },
      {
        "key": "edition-drbench-iclr-2026-d00a3dcdb6",
        "id": "em:dossier-edition:sha256:47d8d33326a498097021dc5754365cbb8f5abfd3e628e90908d2342f0b6c7cf1",
        "canonical_url": "https://proceedings.iclr.cc/paper_files/paper/2026/file/465f22be10e07b301c6ed58f0472f704-Paper-Conference.pdf",
        "license": "unknown"
      },
      {
        "key": "edition-drbench-repo-main-469cce5-4f8964f3e3",
        "id": "em:dossier-edition:sha256:bf5c65b640b321fb75bf8b7f96854f151f834a7d31a2fc9d2bfb783852e7262b",
        "canonical_url": "https://github.com/Ayanami0730/deep_research_bench/commit/469cce54ea7f6a63c163d3d9fec879cf289ec484",
        "license": "Apache-2.0"
      },
      {
        "key": "edition-keplinger-supplement-v1-f6ddb4c04a",
        "id": "em:dossier-edition:sha256:8c80a50cd40cbb31bdaedb6730e8e173e3edc0f3440538dbcc4878eb0997ffd9",
        "canonical_url": "https://data.mendeley.com/datasets/3s73z9zf3c/1",
        "license": "CC BY 4.0"
      },
      {
        "key": "edition-keplinger-supplement-v2-01e44c09d8",
        "id": "em:dossier-edition:sha256:dca82f9514bbd76d7afb655b2fe3d11d98dc6950b90c3065d81afa335bd86418",
        "canonical_url": "https://data.mendeley.com/datasets/3s73z9zf3c/2",
        "license": "CC BY 4.0"
      },
      {
        "key": "edition-keplinger-vor-2025-10ba10f860",
        "id": "em:dossier-edition:sha256:ecbbc5366e2c53ebf6358f0f4c06b7076e158210edd3a081f16af7ab0b029761",
        "canonical_url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13109748/",
        "license": "CC BY-NC 4.0"
      },
      {
        "key": "edition-liveresearchbench-arxiv-v5-f5644763e5",
        "id": "em:dossier-edition:sha256:73c767cab5707e7c87ea4cb96cc6a3434512ae75363371f6d0aad2a365c4e11c",
        "canonical_url": "https://arxiv.org/pdf/2510.14240v5",
        "license": "CC BY-NC-SA 4.0"
      },
      {
        "key": "edition-reportbench-arxiv-v1-25888dc44b",
        "id": "em:dossier-edition:sha256:c674e09fbcbadea10ca1f9c3bb17f5573f020fbc209410c85f3c8f56d53255b6",
        "canonical_url": "https://arxiv.org/html/2508.15804v1",
        "license": "CC BY 4.0"
      },
      {
        "key": "edition-researcherbench-arxiv-v1-39a8b256d7",
        "id": "em:dossier-edition:sha256:e1cb847e48cc813a003705644839d51e54af0b84d06e0f8419d14a03764b93cd",
        "canonical_url": "https://arxiv.org/html/2507.16280v1",
        "license": "arXiv non-exclusive distribution license"
      },
      {
        "key": "edition-url-health-arxiv-v1-85fb934b53",
        "id": "em:dossier-edition:sha256:89224c483a2c88c51351393bd2ae482b8f2642a27b621c5a7a1401b05fe86b2f",
        "canonical_url": "https://arxiv.org/html/2604.03173v1",
        "license": "CC0 1.0"
      }
    ]
  },
  "reproduced_counts": {
    "captured_reports": 8,
    "citation_occurrences": 48,
    "cited_urls": 30,
    "resolving_url_roots": 27,
    "source_work_roots": 11,
    "examined_edition_roots": 14,
    "raw_span_occurrences": 127,
    "accepted_exact_span_roots": 72,
    "em0029_review_supplement_spans": 3,
    "raw_claim_occurrences": 52,
    "candidate_warrant_roots": 7,
    "independently_confirmed_warrant_roots": 0,
    "pending_warrant_groups": 4,
    "independently_rejected_claim_occurrences": 9,
    "inaccessible_citations": 3,
    "unresolved_citations": 34,
    "unsupported_or_force_raised_claims": 20
  },
  "disposition_sets": {
    "pending_warrant_ids": [
      "warrant:citation-verifier-calibration",
      "warrant:liveresearchbench-e1-e2-e3",
      "warrant:researcherbench-faithfulness-groundedness",
      "warrant:url-health-correction-loop"
    ],
    "independently_rejected_claim_occurrence_ids": [
      "V2-SOL-02:R5_deeptrace_audit",
      "V2-SOL-03:r3_deepresearch_bench_fact",
      "V2-SOL-03:r8_search_depth_ablation",
      "V2-SOL-03:r9_verifier_calibration",
      "V2-SOL-04:R1",
      "V2-SOL-04:R2",
      "V2-SOL-04:R3",
      "V2-SOL-04:R4",
      "V2-SOL-04:R8"
    ],
    "inaccessible_citation_occurrence_ids": [
      "V2-SOL-02:S4",
      "V2-SOL-03:s1",
      "V2-TERRA-03:S6"
    ],
    "treatment": "preserved-visible-no-credit"
  },
  "semantic_review": {
    "sentence_to_span_work_edition_license_retrieval_closure": "pass",
    "material_propositions_reviewed": 18,
    "material_span_containment_mismatches": 0,
    "supplement_sentence_gaps_remaining": 0,
    "dependence_dimensions": [
      "model",
      "prompt",
      "retrieval",
      "benchmark-data",
      "source-work",
      "edition",
      "exact-span",
      "method",
      "derivation",
      "upstream-citation"
    ],
    "report_multiplicity_independent_lineage_count": 0,
    "report_multiplicity_unknown_lineage_count": 1,
    "candidate_warrant_independently_confirmed_count": 0,
    "encyclopedia_skeptical_same_dossier_bytes": true,
    "encyclopedia_skeptical_materially_distinct_reasons_and_upshot": true,
    "public_disclosure_noninterference": "pass"
  },
  "github_review_state": {
    "author_head": "16b8e8ebc26948f8d9fa86120c3d495bca3f74e9",
    "state": "open",
    "draft": true,
    "mergeable": true,
    "merge_state": "clean",
    "review_thread_count": 0,
    "unresolved_review_thread_count": 0,
    "effective_main_rules": [
      "deletion-prohibited",
      "non-fast-forward-prohibited",
      "linear-history-required",
      "pull-request-required",
      "review-thread-resolution-required",
      "strict-check-required:check",
      "squash-only"
    ]
  },
  "commands": [
    {
      "command": "git diff --exit-code 75f01214750e9eccc4235cbe2a56eada1c014168 16b8e8ebc26948f8d9fa86120c3d495bca3f74e9 -- accepted EM-0026 packet paths",
      "exit_status": 0,
      "observed": "all accepted answers, traces, readbacks, normalization, ledger, and review receipts are byte-identical"
    },
    {
      "command": "PYTHONPATH=src .venv/bin/python research/how-we-know/agent-citation-lineage/verify_protocol_v2.py --require-traces",
      "exit_status": 0,
      "observed": "protocol valid; exactly eight terminal trace records"
    },
    {
      "command": "PYTHONPATH=src .venv/bin/python research/how-we-know/agent-citation-lineage/build_evidence_ledger.py verify",
      "exit_status": 0,
      "observed": "ledger deterministic and accepted count grammar reproduced"
    },
    {
      "command": "PYTHONPATH=src .venv/bin/python research/how-we-know/agent-citation-lineage/build_candidate.py --check",
      "exit_status": 0,
      "observed": "candidate deterministic; dossier id, 72 accepted roots, three supplements, and zero confirmed warrants reproduced"
    },
    {
      "command": ".venv/bin/ruff check research/how-we-know/agent-citation-lineage/build_candidate.py research/how-we-know/agent-citation-lineage/build_evidence_ledger.py research/how-we-know/agent-citation-lineage/verify_protocol_v2.py",
      "exit_status": 0,
      "observed": "all checks passed"
    },
    {
      "command": "PYTHONPATH=src PATH=$PWD/.venv/bin:$PATH make check PYTHON=.venv/bin/python",
      "exit_status": 0,
      "observed": "accepted-input validation, tests, disclosure audit, independent comparison, deterministic public projection, and unchanged source-tree checks passed"
    }
  ],
  "limitations": [
    "This receipt passes only the bounded EM-0029 research candidate; it does not admit, feature, publish, deploy, or establish Case 002 as accepted knowledge.",
    "The three review-supplement spans close qualification sentences only; they do not change the accepted EM-0026 count of 72 exact span roots and receive no evidentiary warrant credit.",
    "Thirty-four citation occurrences remain unresolved and three carriers remain inaccessible; all remain visible and receive no credit.",
    "Four warrant groups remain pending, nine claim occurrences remain independently rejected, and zero warrant roots are independently confirmed.",
    "The eight reports share declared prompt and runtime lineage; report multiplicity is not independent epistemic corroboration.",
    "The dossier remains draft research over a 2026-08-22 cutoff and does not authorize current, universal, causal, or vendor-wide claims.",
    "No ready-state change, merge, admission, publication, deployment, DNS mutation, package release, credential use, provider call, or spend occurred."
  ]
}